Drawing lines, part 1
A few well deserved notes

Drawing lines, part 2

Sorry to leave you hanging like that. I was...gestating. Seriously, it takes a lot of concentration. It must, or I have no explanation for why I poured myself a cup of tea the other day, noticed it was a bit cool, and popped the teapot in the microwave instead of the cup. Yeah. I walked away, cold cup of tea in my hand, and didn't notice the mix-up until the metal parts of the teapot started arcing and sizzling in the microwave. Haha! Aren't you glad I'm perpetuating my genes on the world?

Anyhow, as I was saying, starting fires. For months - years - the boys have been burning things with magnifying glasses. Scorching leaves, melting plastic figures, that sort of thing. But a few weeks ago Tre and Max were visiting some friends, and when I arrived to pick them up, the four of them were huddled in the gutter around a small fire. It seems they'd been playing with caps - from cap guns - and had discovered a wonderful, wonderful use for the sparks they'd coaxed from them.

And a new era dawned.

Soon the boys were spending most of their spare time outside, making small mounds of newspaper and leaves, and igniting them with their magnifying glasses. They didn't exactly ASK if it was okay, but I knew what they were doing, and I didn't exactly tell them not to, either.

Why?

I'm not sure. I watched them, and they were being very careful, always keeping a bottle of water nearby. They kept the area clear of anything that could catch fire, and the three of them would gather around one fire and just feed it and watch it. Sometimes they came inside with slightly scorched fingers (mostly Raphael, who I SWEAR needs a fear transplant), but never anything significant.

Most of all, I allowed it because they were so enthralled. They would come inside with their hair smelling of smoke, and their eyes shining. An odd side effect of exposure to danger in boys is peace. And joy. Plus, when I say I loved fire as a child, I'm not kidding. I LOVED fire. It was everything that was best about the world - beautiful and warming and magical and dangerous. I could not ever find the way into Narnia, none of the stray keys I found seemed to open doors to another world, and none of my pets ever ever talked to me, no matter how sincerely I assured them it would be okay, but with a match and a pile of splinters, I could bring to life a gorgeous, glowing monster. So I understood the boys' joy.

I did keep an eye on them, because I wanted them to be careful, but also because I wanted to be there if any adults saw them and objected. So you can imagine my irritation when I missed it.

They'd been outside, burning things in the gutter, and I'd been watching out the window while I puttered in the living room. I must have gone to the bathroom or something, because suddenly the three of them came stomping in, trying to outdo each other in scornful mockery of the woman who'd just gotten on their case.

Apparently she had driven up, rolled her window down, and said, "If you don't put that out right now, I'm calling the fire department." They drowned their fire with their water bottle, and she'd driven off, and now they were complaining bitterly.

CJ,I thought of you. And I panicked. What, exactly, would I have done if the fire department had showed up? The police always come along, you know. I DO NOT want to get crossways with CPS, oh my LORD, do I not. So I dropped the boom on the fire starting. For now all burning is disallowed, and the magnifying glasses are only for magnifying things.

I keep thinking about it, wondering if I was wrong or not. It's not easy to defend your right to allow your children to start fires, it's just not. And in this world of parenting-expert-approved answers, it's only getting harder. Maybe I did stray too far outside easily defensible lines.

At the same time, I remember the wilds of my youth and wonder how much those lines are holding out. 

Comments

Loth

Could you build them a designated fire-pit type area in the garden somewhere? Where no nosy neighbours/passers-by can see? Because frankly this seems to be a particularly good way of allowing them a small amount of danger to handle responsibly and it would be a shame if they had to lose it.

A Jen Too Many

I think a fire-pit area would be an excellent idea.

What came to my mind was that you made this decision based on a fear of how other adults might react. Up to this point you felt safe allowing your boys to do this. They had demonstrated responsible behavior in how they handled this (cleared area, water nearby, never leave the fire unattended - were they putting it out safely when they were done?) and you, as their mother, who has years of experience with them, felt they could handle this freedom.

If other people disapprove of something I am doing, it is a good reminder to me to assess my decision. Have I missed something the objectors are seeing? Is this really the good idea I thought it was? Sometimes I find that I have, indeed, missed something. Other times I have decided it was a good idea after all and just ignored the objectors.

I used to play with matches and fire myself as a kid. I probably would have been a lot safer doing it if my parents had known and therefore been able to keep an eye on things.

Amma Always

"Stray too far outside easily defensible lines"? I think not!!! I am full of indignation and scorn for that woman! The First Rule of Interfering With Other Peoples Children is always take your concern to the parent first. And although I know YOU know this I will explain to the blog-o-sphere why this is not dangerous for Tre, Max and Raphael. It is not dangerous because if any of them strayed outside the line of safety, or did anything TRULY dangerous, the other two would fall all over each other in an effort to be the first to rat on the evil-doer!

Amma Always

P.S. Have you ever told your readers why YOU had a fire pit in which to build fires as a child?

Sheryl

I agree with everyone. I don't think there's anything wrong with kids building little fires. Just do it out of sight of the neighbors.

hollygee

Everyone seems to have my answer -- that I got from reading Joshilyn's post about her father building her a fire pit when she was young for her obsession.

Aimee

Just one small amendment I would suggest to Sheryl's comment above: there's nothing wrong with kids building small fires, as long as they don't live in a Santa Ana area. I live in San Diego, and the thought of kids building fires terrifies me. Not because I don't understand the fascination -- I was fascinated with fire as a kid, too, but I lived in an area that got lots of rain. Here in San Diego, which has burned twice in five years, it's a scary thought.

Wendy

Sweet Kira, I am in complete agreement with the above. Let them build the fires. Find a place where the neighbors can't interfere and let them go at it. My backyard as a kid (in arizona where everything is dry and flamable) had a large dirt area (15'x15') that we used to use for digging up dinosaur bones and making GI Joe trenches that we filled with water. One summer, we spent the ENTIRE summer wrapping matches in aluminum foil and making little fire rockets out of them (when they ignite, the sudden burst of fire shoots out the bottom of the aluminum foil and if you set it up right, the match fly about 3-5 feet) and my mom continually supplied us with box after box of matches. Let them go for it. They're learning now while they're young how to be responsible and not doing anyone any harm in the process.

Maggie

nosey neighbors, school administrators labeling children and familes can become dangerous territory.

It's a sad, scared of it's own shadow, politically correct world we live in, filled with mean people who don't understand or tolerate people who are different from them.

Ask this mother of an ADHD child who has had to have more than one psych evaluation done on her child to appease the administration.

We celebrate and snub our noses to convention everytime they fail to make us think less of ourselves because we don't play by their rules.

carrien (she laughs at the days)

Ditto on the fire pit. Along with a fire safety lecture for good measure.

I had a fire pit in the back yard when I was a kid too. My high school nickname was fire goddess. I can still get almost anything to turn into a raging bonfire with just one match.

ps. did you ever build a log cabin out of matches and then set it on fire?

Megan

We have a fire pit, and the boys love it.

Everybody's happy!

:)

The One True Josh

Well, they're always welcome to come to their uncle's house in Phoenix. All the combustable stuff is long gone anyhow. They can burn things in the (desert-landscaped) backyard, with the pool there to douse things. No one will complain.

They can have a contest to see who keeps the most inches of eyebrow.

Jill

Another vote here for the fire pit.

Trust your own instincts about your own kids. As long as they are responsible about it, I don't see the problem.

The comments to this entry are closed.